"Get your facts first, and then you can distort them as much as you please." (Mark Twain)

Monday, July 17, 2006

Revisionism 

Via Josh Marshall (or, rather, a guest poster at his joint), I saw this jaw-dropping comment from David Brooks:
f you look at the jihadists, they had a victory in '79 by pushing the Soviets out of Afghanistan. They pushed the U.S. out of Lebanon. The pushed the Israelis out of Gaza and out of Lebanon. They're probably pushing the U.S. out of Iraq. They are on the march.

Iraq is part of that, but it's not the whole story. They are on the march, and they're sidelining the reasonable people in the Middle East, who may be the majority, but right now what's happening in the Middle East is the Israeli public opinion has gone to the center, for withdrawal, but Arab decision makers have gone to the extremes, to Hamas and Hezbollah.

Okay, who spotted the moment of idiocy? Let's break it down: "They" - the "jihadists," that is - are on the march. Reasonable people are being sidelined. And this is merely the continuation of a long process, which began with the Soviet defeat in Afghanistan.

Well, now, hold on there one minute. The "reasonable people" who were sidelined in Afghnaistan were the Soviet army, and their defeat came at the hands of what was virtually a US proxy. If Brooks and his ilk want to argue that America's arming of the mujahideen was a proximate cause of our current situation, I'm right there with them (and, by the way, if you have not yet read Charlie Wilson's War, now would be a good time). In retrospect, it has not turned out well, and I will leave it for another day to ponder whether we should have predicted that from the beginning. But it is clearly either (a) ignorant or (b) dishonest to list the Soviet defeat as an example of the Islamists sidelining "reasonable people," without bothering to mention that we made it happen. Of course, this being Brooks, perhaps it is both ignorant and dishonest.

 

Comments:

 

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

What do you want from your next vacation, romance, adventure, maybe some golf?You can book everything you will need to get you from your front door to the holiday of your dreams and you have our best price guarantee.
hotels, vacations, cruises
hotels, vacations, cruises
We guarantee the lowest price on flights, hotels, vacations, cruises and activities.
hotels, vacations, cruises
hotels, vacations, cruises
Free Ringtone.Free download, free ringtones!
ringtone
Las Vegas, Las Vegas Hotels and Airport Las Vegas
las-vegas
This is a location to enjoy the world of costume and fashion!
costume
romance
 
Great post, Rod. Of course, debunking Brooks is becoming a hobby for millions!
 
Do your homework before considering world travel.

For the most pleasureable vacation possible, check out your options for world travel.

Visit world travel
 
Hello, guys. Sorry for my English ,I'm from Spain. It's an interesting site . And I wonder, where do you live (country and maybe city)?
 
Dear Internet Friend,
Could you use an extra $500-$1000 a week?I highly recommend ExpresspaidSurveys.With ExpresspaidSurveys you can make $175 an hour online from the comfort of Your Own Home.
Simply sign up and start giving your opinions for cash.Their database of companies actually pay you for taking online surveys and participating in focus groups.
Visit them by clicking here:To stop further messages, please click on the unsubscription link.If you wish to be put into our master ban list, click on another unsubscription link placed
at the new page which is opened, when you click on the previous unsubscription link.If these links do not work due to technical problems, please try again later.
 
Post a Comment